Don’t die of ignorance: Mass Observation and the AIDS crisis
In an episode of Russell T. Davies’s new drama, It’s a Sin, the protagonists, a group of young gay men, cluster around the television in their battered but cheerful London flat. Crammed onto the sofa, they have obviously anticipated this moment.
But what they are watching isn’t 1986’s latest, now nostalgic, primetime hit, but a new government advertisement.
A leaflet on AIDS from the National Union of Public Employees was included with T1686's response to the spring 1987 directive. Image © Mass Observation Archive Trustees. Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.
There is now a danger that has become a threat to us all. It is a deadly disease and there is no known cure.
From Mass Observation's spring 1987 directive. Image © Mass Observation Archive Trustees. Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.
The disease was of course AIDS, and in It’s a Sin we watch it stalk and circle our flatmates, and finally overwhelm them with ill health, hospitals, infirmity, death and grief. The social-history project Mass Observation, whose 1980s material has been published by AM, asked its respondents about their thoughts on the government’s AIDS awareness campaign in the spring of 1987.
The line of questioning did not mention any groups of people, as indeed AIDS was ‘a threat to us all’. But the numbers showed that when it hit the developed world in the early 1980s it most significantly afflicted homosexual men; and though there were high-profile exceptions, such as the tennis star Arthur Ashe and the model Gia Carangi, a steady drip of famous gay male victims reinforced among the wider public the discussion of AIDS as a disease more or less of gay men.
The bulk of the Mass Observation responses, which address general feelings around AIDS as much as the campaign against it, are no exception.
From observer B1891's response to the spring 1987 directive. Image © Mass Observation Archive Trustees. Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Observer B1891 is one of many whose response mixes the customary measured, liberal attitudes typical of Mass Observers with the increased opposition to homosexuality which went hand-in-hand with the rise of AIDS into the British popular consciousness.
Although she disagrees, she states, with the popular view that the virus represented a deserved punishment of gay men, she speculates that the money and effort put into fighting the disease ‘for a relatively few people’ could have been better spent – though that she might think differently if she knew any sufferers.
B663, meanwhile, begins by splitting people with AIDS into innocent and guilty, according to how they have contracted it, but goes on to reassure us that, like most women, she feels that what two adults get up to in private is their own affair – an odd juxtaposition:
From observer B663's response to the spring 1987 directive. Image © Mass Observation Archive Trustees. Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.
A handful of respondents, however, had personal experience with the virus and its effects. A1108 says he has a friend who has died and another who is ill and gives short shrift to the idea that the state and society are coming to gay men’s rescue by paying AIDS attention:
From observer A1108's response to the spring 1987 directive. Image © Mass Observation Archive Trustees. Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Another gay observer, B1106, concurs with this view, also mentioning the Terrence Higgins Trust as an example of efforts gay men have made themselves to spread awareness of the virus and help mitigate its effects. He also notes that now more is understood about AIDS, attacking the people widely held responsible for it has become more prevalent and, presumably, acceptable:
From observer B1106's response to the spring 1987 directive. Image © Mass Observation Archive Trustees. Further reproduction is prohibited without permission.
The Mass Observers’ responses to the new disease in their midst show a society in which homosexual behaviour was legal but alien to most and still highly mistrusted by many.
More than three decades on, there remains no cure for AIDS, but, as the British Social Attitudes Survey linked above shows, opinions of gay people have been turned on their heads – as the making and primetime broadcast of It’s a Sin happily demonstrates.
About the collection
Mass Observation Project is out now.
Recent posts
James Prinsep, the son of an East India Company merchant and government official, holds a notable place in Indian history for his work in the Indian Mint and standardising currency. Records from East India Company, module VII show how Prinsep, and the British-run East India Company more broadly, reshaped India’s currency to suit their economic and administrative needs.
Foreign Office, Consulate and Legation Files, China: 1830-1939 contains a huge variety of material touching on life in China through the eyes of the British representatives stationed there. Nick Jackson, Senior Editor at AM, looks at an example from this wealth of content, one diplomat’s exploration of Chinese family relationships and how this narrative presented them to a British audience.